H.3.2 Is Marxism "socialism from below"?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.3 What are the myths of ...Some Marxists, such as the International Socialist Tendency, like to portray their tradition as being "socialism from below." Under "socialism from below," they place the ideas of Marx, Engels, Lenin and Trotsky, arguing that they and they alone have continued this, the true, ideal of socialism (Hal Draper's essay "The Two Souls of Socialism" seems to have been the first to argue along these lines).
Related QuestionsWhat is socialism?
Just da FAQ'sThe word "socialism" also means many different things to different people. There is a scientific definition and at least two commonly believed bullshit definitions. The following chart may help:
Related QuestionsWhere has socialism existed?
Just da FAQ'sSame as above. Scientific socialism (ie: the rule of society by the working class) has never existed (except in embryonic form such as the Paris Commune of 1871 or the early period of the 1917 revolution in Russia). The words "communism" and "socialism" are commonly mis-used to describe a society in which a popular revolution against the ruling class and foreign imperialism results in a radical transformation of property relations and an improvement in the living conditions of the masses.
Related QuestionsIs Marxism scientific?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - Appendix 3.5 - Reply to er...As Lenin states, 'the ideas of Marx are all powerful, because they are true'! We have the science of dialectics on our side, not idealism, mysticism or theology. Our philosophy is solid as a rock." Firstly, dialectics is not a science. Secondly, quoting Lenin on the wonders of Marxism is like quoting the Pope on the joys of Catholicism. Thirdly, the only rocks around are in the heads of Trotskyists if they really think this nonsense about anarchism.
Related QuestionsWhat is National Socialism?
FAQNational Socialism is simply the application of the laws of Nature-the operating laws of God in this universe-to human affairs. As such, it incorporates a specific and special call to Aryankind.
Related QuestionsH.1.1 What was Bakunin's critique of Marxism?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.1 Have anarchists always...Bakunin and Marx famously clashed in the first International Working Men's Association between 1868 and 1872. This conflict helped clarify the anarchist opposition to the ideas of Marxism and can be considered as the first major theoretical analysis and critique of Marxism by anarchists.
Related QuestionsH.3.6 Is Marxism the only revolutionary politics which have worked?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.3 What are the myths of ...Some Marxists will dismiss our arguments, and anarchism, out of hand. This is because anarchism has not lead a "successful" revolution while Marxism has. The fact, they assert, that there has never been a serious anarchist revolutionary movement, let alone an anarchist revolution, in the whole of history proves that Marxism works. For some Marxists, practice determines validity. Whether something is true or not is not decided intellectually in wordy publications and debates, but in reality.
Related QuestionsIs managed care socialism?
UW-Cooperative Extension Health Policy Information--FAQIn its present application, it¹s just the opposite. It¹s being used as a tool for "free enterprise" and fierce competition. A socialist health plan would guarantee access for all Americans. There is nothing required of managed care that would lead to universal access.
Related QuestionsWhy Socialism is considered to be evil?
Socialism is evil because it denies the origin of life, the Creator, and replaces it with humanism/naturalism, which claims that the supreme goodness is in human and it does not emanate from God.
Related QuestionsCan Socialism be merged with Church teaching?
No. Every member of the Church is excommunicated automatically from it, once socialism is adopted as a conviction.Because it contradicts the Credo of our belief. They are incompatible.
Related QuestionsDo you sympathise with National Socialism (Nazis)?
VivaMalta - FAQWhile National Socialism had many fine aspects in relation to community-orientated politics, environmentalism, technological innovation, active encouragement of a healthy life-style, racial-genetic improvement, cultural and traditional preservation, etc.... it was a complete catastrophe for Europe with its Jingoistic aggressive need for "living space" and dogmatic self-righteous national glorification against its own race of people living outside its national boundaries.
Related QuestionsWhat is this "self-managed society" you are for? Is this socialism?
Self-management means having a say over decisions that affect you; it means having control over your life. This means people being able to collectively manage the industries they work in; it also means controlling the places you live in. Corporate hierarchies in industry would be dismantled and replaced by workers direct management, through democratic industrial organizations rooted in face-to-face meetings. To most people in the U.S., "socialism" means the government running things.
Related QuestionsH.3 What are the myths of state socialism?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.3 What are the myths of ...Ask most people what socialism means and they will point to the former Soviet Union, China, Cuba and a host of other authoritarian, centralised and oppressive party dictatorships. These regimes have in common two things. Firstly, the claim that their rulers are Marxists or socialists. Secondly, that they have successfully alienated millions of working class people from the very idea of socialism.
Related QuestionsH.3.3 Is Leninism "socialism from below"?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.3 What are the myths of ...discussed in the last section, Marx and Engels left their followers with an ambiguous legacy. On the one hand, there are elements of "socialism from below" in their politics (most explicitly in Marx's comments on the libertarian influenced Paris Commune). On the other, there are distinctly centralist and statist themes in their work. From this legacy, Leninism took the statist themes. Which explains why anarchists think the idea of Leninism being "socialism from below" is incredible.
Related QuestionsChange Obama can believe in: Socialism?
BlogNetNews.com » Mob » Heavy-Handed PoliticsCampaign workers for Senator and presidential candidate Barack Obama are under fire for displaying a flag featuring communist hero Che Guevara. But Obama has his own controversial connections. He is, in fact, an associate of a Chicago-based socialist group with ties to the...
Related QuestionsIs anarchism the same thing as socialism?
Anarchist Theory FAQ Version 5.2If we accept one traditional definition of socialism -- "advocacy of government ownership of the means of production" -- it seems that anarchists are not socialists by definition. But if by socialism we mean something more inclusive, such as "advocacy of the strong restriction or abolition of private property," then the question becomes more complex. Under the second proffered definition, some anarchists are socialists, but others are not.
Related QuestionsH.1 Have anarchists always opposed state socialism?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.1 Have anarchists always...Yes. Anarchists have always argued that real socialism cannot be created using a state. The basic core of the argument is simple. Socialism implies equality, yet the state signifies inequality -- inequality in terms of power. As we argued in section B.2, anarchists consider one of the defining aspects of the state is its hierarchical nature. In other words, the delegation of power into the hands of a few. As such, it violates the core idea of socialism, namely social equality.
Related QuestionsH.3.12 Is big business the precondition for socialism?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.3 What are the myths of ...A key idea in most forms of Marxism is that the evolution of capitalism itself will create the preconditions for socialism. This is because capitalism tends to result in big business and, correspondingly, increased numbers of workers subject to the "socialised" production process within the workplace. The conflict between the socialised means of production and their private ownership is at the heart of the Marxist case for socialism.
Related QuestionsIs not Technocracy very similar to Socialism or Communism?
Unofficial Technocracy FAQ Ver. 1.2 (HTML)What do Technocrats mean by Social Change? Their use of the term seems to differ from that of the popular understanding.
Related QuestionsWHAT IS MARXISM-LENINISM-MAOISM, GONZALO THOUGHT?
PCP Frequently Asked QuestionsThe ideology of the international proletariat is generated with the historical process of the class struggle. First it emerged as Marxism, which led to Marxism-Leninism and later on to Marxism-Leninism-Maoism. Thus the scientific ideology of the proletariat has three stages: 1) Marxism; 2.) Leninism; 3)Maoism.
Related QuestionsWhy don't you post documents about Marxism, the Declaration of Rights of Man, or the Constitution?
Sacred-texts.com: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)This site has a very specific list of topics which it covers. These texts, although some people consider them sacred in a broader sense, fall outside the sites' mission. The spelling of Sanskrit terms reflects the transcription in the original book (in this case the Sacred Books of the East, volume 1 and 15) which I scanned it from. I do not alter the transcription of public domain texts, such as the Sacred Books of the East.
Related QuestionsA.1.3 Why is anarchism also called libertarian socialism?
Frequently Asked Questions about AnarchismMany anarchists, seeing the negative nature of the definition of "anarchism," have used other terms to emphasize the inherently positive and constructive aspect of their ideas. The most common terms used are "free socialism," "free communism," "libertarian socialism," and "libertarian communism." For anarchists, libertarian socialism, libertarian communism, and anarchism are virtually interchangeable.
Related QuestionsCommunism/socialism sounded nice on paper, but wasn't so practical. How are you guys different?
Liberty Round Table FAQ: StrategyLiberty Round Table strategy is not utopian. The most radical thing about the LRT vision is that it doesn't condemn mankind for perceived "baseness", nor does it depend on the sudden appearance of superhuman wisdom and benevolence. LRT does not claim that all evil and sadness will disappear if people would but follow us. All we are saying is that things will be better if we try to align human institutions so that they are consistent with human nature. Personally, I am an optimist.
Related QuestionsInfoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.1 Have anarchists always opposed state socialism?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.1 Have anarchists always...Quick Links Infoshop Home AMP (About Us) Store Anarchist FAQ Forums InfoJournals Calendar Portals Features Calendar Directory Infoshop A to Z Site Map Add a Link! AMP Projects Breaking Glass Press Practical Anarchy Infoshop News I-News Home News Archive Library News Prison News Science News Youth News By language Deutsche Español Francais Italiano Português Svenska Wikis OpenWiki Matrix Science Fiction & Fantasy Infoshop Portals Activism Libertarian Marxism Anarchism Portal Anti.
Related QuestionsH.2.5 Do anarchists think "full blown" socialism will be created overnight?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.2 What parts of anarchis...Another area in which Marxists misrepresent anarchism is in the assertion that anarchists believe a completely socialist society (an ideal or "utopian" society, in other words) can be created "overnight." As Marxist Bertell Ollman puts it, "[u]nlike anarcho-communists, none of us [Marxists] believe that communism will emerge full blown from a socialist revolution. Some kind of transition and period of indeterminate length for it to occur are required." [Bertell Ollman (ed.
Related QuestionsInfoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.3 What are the myths of state socialism?
Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - H.3 What are the myths of ...Quick Links Infoshop Home AMP (About Us) Store Anarchist FAQ Forums InfoJournals Calendar Portals Features Calendar Directory Infoshop A to Z Site Map Add a Link! AMP Projects Breaking Glass Press Practical Anarchy Infoshop News I-News Home News Archive Library News Prison News Science News Youth News By language Deutsche Español Francais Italiano Português Svenska Wikis OpenWiki Matrix Science Fiction & Fantasy Infoshop Portals Activism Libertarian Marxism Anarchism Portal Anti.
Related Questions